Coaching clients with an all-or-nothing mindset can be incredibly difficult, but there are ways to help these clients. If you’ve been coaching for any length of time, you’ve likely encountered clients trapped in the “all-or-nothing” mindset. It’s a pattern of thinking that can derail even the most motivated individuals. In fact, it usually is the most motivated individuals who suffer from it.
This mindset often sounds like, “If I can’t work out for an hour, why bother at all?” or “I ate one biscuit, so the whole day is ruined.” As a coach, your role isn’t just to provide plans and strategies but to help clients reframe these thoughts and embrace balance over perfection.
Let’s dive into building your understanding of the all-or-nothing mindset, and some strategies for coaching clients with an all-or-nothing mindset.
Why the All-or-Nothing Mindset is So Common
The all-or-nothing mindset stems from a mix of societal pressures, unrealistic expectations, and even past experiences. Many clients have been conditioned to think that success requires perfection. They believe a single misstep is a failure, leading to a cycle of over-restriction followed by burnout or bingeing. Understanding the root of this mindset is the first step to helping clients shift away from it.
Societal messaging plays a big role. From fitness influencers promoting rigid routines to diet culture emphasising strict rules, clients often internalise the belief that only extremes yield results.
This mindset can be compounded by personal experiences, such as trying overly restrictive diets or programs in the past that demanded unsustainable levels of effort. When they inevitably “failed,” they were left feeling defeated and believing they lacked discipline.
As a coach, it’s essential to acknowledge these influences and validate their challenges while offering a new, more sustainable approach.
Identifying the Mindset in Clients
Coaching clients with an all-or-nothing mindset is difficult, but it is made more difficult because coaches don’t know how to identify the mindset in their clients. Before you can help clients overcome the all-or-nothing mindset, you need to be able to identify it. Many clients may not even realise they’re stuck in this way of thinking, so it’s up to you to look for the signs and dig deeper when necessary.
Common Signs: Behaviors and Phrases
Clients often exhibit telltale behaviours or say things that reveal their all-or-nothing thinking. Watch for statements like:
- “I missed a day, and it ruined my week.”
- “If I’m not doing it perfectly, what’s the point?”
- “I ate something ‘bad’ today, so I might as well go all out.”
- “I’ll start over on Monday.”
Behaviourally, clients may:
- Skip workouts entirely if they can’t commit to their full routine.
- Avoid tracking their meals after a single indulgence.
- Exhibit yo-yo patterns in their efforts, swinging between intense focus and complete disengagement.
Recognising these signs is the first step to intervening effectively.
Assessment Tools: Questions and Techniques
To uncover whether a client is stuck in this mindset, you can use specific questions and techniques to probe their thoughts and attitudes. Some effective questions include:
- “What does a ‘successful’ day look like for you?”
- “How do you feel after you deviate from your plan?”
- “What do you think needs to happen for you to feel like you’re making progress?”
These questions can reveal rigid expectations or a fear of imperfection. Additionally, you can use reflective listening to reframe their responses.
For example:
Client: “I didn’t work out today, so I feel like I’m falling behind.”
Coach: “It sounds like you’re equating one missed workout with losing progress. Let’s explore how we can view today differently.”
Another technique is to use journaling exercises. Ask clients to write down their thoughts when they feel they’ve “failed.” This helps them identify recurring patterns and provides you with insights to guide discussions. You can also introduce self-assessment tools like rating their effort or feelings on a scale of 1 to 10, which allows them to see progress as a spectrum rather than a binary success/failure.
Strategies for Coaching Clients With An All-or-Nothing Mindset
Now, I know coaching clients with and all-or-nothing mindset can be incredibly difficult, so I want to go through some strategies you can use to help these clients. Developing the skills needed to help these individuals takes time, but once you crack it, you will be able to help a lot more people.
Step 1: Normalise Imperfection
One of the most powerful tools in your coaching arsenal is reassurance. Remind your clients that perfection isn’t realistic, nor is it necessary for success. You can help illustrate this by sharing examples from your own journey or from other clients (with their permission) to illustrate that consistency, not flawlessness, leads to results.
For example, you might say:
“Nobody eats perfectly all the time, not even professional athletes or nutritionists. What matters is what you do most of the time, not what you do occasionally.”
To drive this point home, use metaphors or relatable scenarios. For example, compare their fitness journey to driving a car. If you take a wrong turn, you don’t abandon the trip, you recalibrate and continue toward your destination. This helps reduce the fear of making mistakes and opens the door to a more flexible approach.
Step 2: Focus on Small Wins
When clients feel like they’ve “failed,” it’s often because they’re measuring success with an all-or-nothing lens. Shift their focus to small, actionable wins. For example:
- If they couldn’t fit in their usual workout, celebrate that they took a 10-minute walk.
- If they veered off their nutrition plan, highlight their effort to make a better choice at the next meal.
Reframing success as a collection of small victories can significantly shift their mindset. To make this concept more tangible, encourage clients to keep a “wins journal,” where they log even the smallest achievements daily. Whether it’s drinking an extra glass of water, opting for stairs instead of the elevator, or prepping one meal ahead, these actions add up over time. Regularly reviewing this journal together can reinforce the importance of small, consistent actions.
Step 3: Teach the Continuum Scale
The continuum scale is a fantastic visual tool to help clients understand that their choices don’t have to be black or white. For instance, you can draw a line from 1 to 10, where 1 represents skipping all movement for the day and 10 represents completing their full workout. Then ask:
“If you can’t do a 10 today, what about a 5 or a 6?”
You can also apply this concept to nutrition. Instead of labelling foods as “good” or “bad,” encourage clients to think of meals on a spectrum. A “10” might be a perfectly balanced plate, while a “5” could be grabbing a sandwich from the shop instead of skipping lunch altogether or eating junk food. This approach helps clients see that even moderate efforts are valuable and keeps them engaged rather than giving up altogether.
For further reinforcement, provide real-life examples. Share stories of clients who embraced the continuum scale and found it transformative. This not only normalises the concept but also shows that it’s a practical, proven strategy for success.
Step 4: Reframe Setbacks as Learning Opportunities
Clients often view setbacks as failures. Teach them to see these moments as feedback instead. Ask questions like:
- “What do you think led to this choice?”
- “What could you do differently next time?”
By helping clients analyse their choices without judgment, you create a safe space for growth. Share a framework for reframing setbacks. For example, if a client misses a workout, guide them to focus on the factors they can control next time, like scheduling it earlier or preparing their gym bag in advance. Encourage them to view each setback as an experiment rather than a verdict on their ability.
Reinforce this mindset through consistent reminders and feedback. Over time, clients will begin to approach challenges with curiosity instead of frustration, transforming their perspective on what it means to make progress.
Step 5: Emphasise the “80/20 Rule”
The 80/20 rule (aiming to make healthy choices 80% of the time while allowing flexibility 20% of the time) is a game-changer for clients stuck in all-or-nothing thinking. Explain how this approach creates sustainability and prevents burnout. Help them identify what their 20% looks like (e.g., a favourite treat or a less-structured weekend meal) so they can enjoy it guilt-free.
To make this concept actionable, work with clients to identify their personal “80%” habits. For example, this might include meal prepping during the week or prioritising sleep. Then, help them define their “20%,” ensuring they feel empowered to enjoy their choices without guilt. Over time, clients will see that flexibility doesn’t hinder their progress, it enhances it.
You can also use visuals, such as pie charts or calendars, to illustrate the balance. Seeing their habits in context can help clients internalise the idea that perfection isn’t necessary for success.
Step 6: Create Non-Negotiables
Non-negotiables are small, achievable habits that clients commit to no matter what. These might include drinking a certain amount of water daily, getting 7-8 hours of sleep, or eating one serving of vegetables at each meal. These foundational habits build momentum and remind clients that even on their “off” days, they’re still making progress.
Work with clients to identify 2-3 non-negotiables that align with their goals and lifestyle. For example, if a client struggles with hydration, their non-negotiable might be drinking a glass of water before every meal. By focusing on these baseline habits, clients maintain a sense of accomplishment even during challenging periods. Regularly revisiting and adjusting these non-negotiables ensures they remain relevant and achievable.
Step 7: Celebrate Progress, Not Perfection
Finally, make it a priority to celebrate your clients’ progress, no matter how small it may seem. Recognise their efforts and improvements, whether it’s managing stress more effectively, choosing healthier snacks, or simply showing up for their session. Positive reinforcement strengthens their motivation and reinforces the idea that success isn’t about perfection, it’s about progress.
Encourage clients to celebrate themselves as well. Suggest creating a “success jar,” where they write down daily wins and reflect on them during moments of self-doubt. Highlight their achievements during sessions, and use metrics beyond weight or appearance to measure success, such as increased energy levels, improved strength, or better sleep. Focusing on the habits they engage in, rather than the results they get is also helpful.
Avoiding Common Pitfalls
As you guide clients toward overcoming the all-or-nothing mindset, it’s crucial to avoid certain pitfalls that could unintentionally hinder their progress.
Overloading Clients: Why Too Much Advice Can Backfire
As coaches, we often have a wealth of knowledge and strategies to share, but bombarding clients with too much information or too many tasks at once can feel overwhelming. When clients feel like they need to implement multiple changes simultaneously, it can reinforce their all-or-nothing mindset rather than help them overcome it.
Instead, focus on introducing one or two manageable changes at a time. For example, if a client is struggling with nutrition, start with a single habit like including a vegetable at each meal rather than overhauling their entire diet. As they build confidence and momentum, you can gradually layer in additional strategies. This incremental approach fosters sustainability and ensures clients don’t feel paralysed by the enormity of their goals.
Unrealistic Promises: The Dangers of Guaranteeing Quick Fixes
Another common pitfall is setting unrealistic expectations for how quickly clients can shift their mindset or see results. While it’s tempting to provide optimistic timelines, especially when clients are eager for change, doing so can backfire if they don’t meet these expectations. Unrealistic promises can lead to frustration, self-doubt, and further entrenchment in the all-or-nothing mindset.
Be honest and transparent with your clients about the process. Emphasise that overcoming deep-seated thought patterns takes time and consistent effort. Use language that highlights progress rather than perfection, such as “We’re aiming for steady improvement” or “This is about building lifelong habits, not a quick fix.”
Setting realistic expectations helps clients stay motivated and focused on the journey rather than an arbitrary endpoint.
Final Thoughts on Coaching Clients With An All-or-Nothing Mindset
Helping clients overcome the all-or-nothing mindset takes patience, empathy, and consistent reinforcement of healthier ways of thinking. As a coach, you have the unique opportunity to guide them toward a more balanced and sustainable approach to fitness and nutrition.
By normalising imperfection, focusing on small wins, teaching tools like the continuum scale, and avoiding common pitfalls, you’ll empower your clients to stay the course and ultimately achieve their goals. Not through perfection, but through persistence and balance.
We have a lot of free content available in our content hub, if you want to learn more. If you want even more free information, you can follow us on Instagram, YouTube or listen to the podcast. You can always stay up to date with our latest content by subscribing to our newsletter.
Finally, if you want to learn how to coach nutrition, then consider our Nutrition Coach Certification course, and if you want to learn to get better at exercise program design, then consider our course on exercise program design. We do have other courses available too. If you don’t understand something, or you just need clarification, you can always reach out to us on Instagram or via email.
Paddy Farrell
Hey, I'm Paddy!
I am a coach who loves to help people master their health and fitness. I am a personal trainer, strength and conditioning coach, and I have a degree in Biochemistry and Biomolecular Science. I have been coaching people for over 10 years now.
When I grew up, you couldn't find great health and fitness information, and you still can't really. So my content aims to solve that!
I enjoy training in the gym, doing martial arts and hiking in the mountains (around Europe, mainly). I am also an avid reader of history, politics and science. When I am not in the mountains, exercising or reading, you will likely find me in a museum.