As a coach, you’re in a powerful position to help people improve their lives through exercise, nutrition, and lifestyle habits. But one common mistake that many new coaches make, often with the best intentions, is providing meal plans to their clients. Meal plans don’t help your clients long term, and you are doing them a disservice by providing them. While it might seem like a great way to help someone eat better, meal plans are not only ineffective, but also often fall outside of your legal scope of practice.
Let’s break down why meal plans don’t help your clients, and what you should do instead.
Why Meal Plans Don’t Help Your Clients
Understanding why meal plans don’t help your clients will allow you to understand how to actually help your clients in a more comprehensive and holistic way. So why don’t meal plans help?
1. They Don’t Teach Sustainable Habits
When you hand a client a strict meal plan, you’re essentially giving them a script to follow. But what happens when life gets in the way? What if they go on holidays, eat out, or simply get bored of eating the same meals? Without the skills to make their own healthy choices, they’re likely to revert to old habits the moment the meal plan ends.
Strict meal plans create dependency rather than empowerment. When clients don’t learn how to navigate real-world food choices, they struggle the moment the plan is no longer available. Instead of fostering independence, meal plans make them feel like they need constant direction from an external source. This prevents them from developing their own decision-making abilities regarding food, which is essential for long-term success.
Furthermore, meal plans often promote an all-or-nothing mentality. If a client deviates from the prescribed meals, they might feel like they have failed, leading to frustration, guilt, and even abandonment of their health goals. By contrast, a flexible, intentional eating approach encourages clients to adapt to different situations and make healthier choices without the pressure of following a rigid set of rules.
Instead of giving clients a rigid plan, focus on teaching them how to build balanced meals using principles like portion control, macronutrient balance, and mindful eating. When they understand the “why” behind their nutrition, they can make informed choices in any situation. By educating clients on how to plan their meals using simple guidelines, they gain confidence in their ability to make smart food choices in various settings, whether at home, at a restaurant, or while travelling.
2. Meal Plans Are Often Unrealistic
Many meal plans are designed with a “perfect world” in mind, where your client has the time, money, and motivation to prep every meal exactly as written. But let’s be honest, the real world isn’t like that. Clients have busy schedules, social obligations, and personal food preferences.
A rigid meal plan doesn’t account for these variables, which can make clients feel like they’ve “failed” when they inevitably deviate from the plan. Instead of setting them up for frustration, work on flexible nutrition strategies that fit their lifestyle.
Meal plans also fail to accommodate real-life hurdles such as food availability, financial constraints, and unexpected life events. For example, a client may find that a meal plan requires ingredients that aren’t available at their local shop, or they may struggle to afford the recommended foods consistently. Others may simply lack the time or desire to prepare the meals exactly as prescribed, leading to frustration and feelings of inadequacy.
Instead of prescribing an inflexible meal plan, work with clients to create realistic meal planning strategies that fit their personal preferences, schedules, and resources. Teach them how to make quick, nutritious meals with the ingredients they already have and how to adjust their eating habits based on their daily needs.
3. They Ignore Individual Preferences and Needs
Everyone has unique dietary needs, food preferences, and cultural influences. What works for one person may not work for another. Meal plans often fail because they don’t take into account personal preferences, allergies, food sensitivities, or ethical considerations like vegetarianism or religious dietary restrictions.
Rather than prescribing a set list of meals, encourage clients to explore foods they enjoy within a balanced framework. Help them experiment with healthier versions of their favourite meals and make gradual adjustments.
Ignoring personal preferences can make a meal plan feel like a restrictive diet rather than a sustainable lifestyle change. For example, a client who dislikes certain vegetables or proteins will struggle to adhere to a plan that includes them. Similarly, someone with cultural or religious dietary restrictions may find it challenging to follow a plan that doesn’t align with their traditions.
Instead of dictating specific meals, help clients develop their own personalised eating strategies by identifying nutritious foods they already enjoy and incorporating them into a balanced approach. Provide them with broad food lists, portion size guidelines, and meal-building strategies that allow for customisation based on their individual needs.
Additionally, encourage intentional eating and food flexibility. When clients understand the principles of good nutrition and learn to listen to their hunger and fullness cues, they can make sustainable choices that feel natural rather than forced. The key is to make healthy eating feel accessible, enjoyable, and adaptable rather than restrictive and overwhelming.
But these are only the tip of the iceberg as to why meal plans don’t help your clients. There are many other reasons why meal plans don’t work, including:
- They Create Unrealistic Expectations: Clients expect meal plans to be a magic fix, but they rarely account for real-life situations such as eating out, travel, or changing schedules. Clients often struggle to stick to a rigid plan and may experience stress or guilt when they cannot follow it exactly. By providing a meal plan, you are setting the expectation that following the meal plan exactly is the only way to succeed.
- They Don’t Account for Behavioural and Emotional Eating: Meal plans focus on food selection but don’t address habits, cravings, stress eating, or emotional triggers that influence food choices. Without addressing the psychological side of eating, clients may continue to engage in unhealthy patterns.
- They Can Lead to a Restrictive Mindset: Following a set meal plan can make clients feel restricted, which can result in binge eating or yo-yo dieting once they go off the plan. This approach can create an unhealthy relationship with food and a cycle of dieting and failing. Meal plans create a very “on plan” “off plan” mentality that can be really harmful for your clients relationship with food.
- They Are Hard to Sustain Long-Term: Most clients struggle to stick to meal plans beyond a few weeks, leading to frustration and a return to old habits. Life is unpredictable, and an inflexible meal plan does not account for necessary adjustments. You want to set your client up for long term success, not just transient success if they can stick to the meal plan.
- They Don’t Promote Critical Thinking About Food: Clients following a plan don’t learn to make decisions about meals in various situations, leaving them vulnerable when they no longer have a guide. Teaching clients how to make their own informed choices is far more beneficial.
- They May Not Align with Clients’ Unique Preferences and Needs: Many meal plans don’t take into account individual taste preferences, cultural dietary habits, food allergies, or health conditions. Customising nutrition approaches ensures sustainability.
- They Don’t Foster Independence: Clients who rely on meal plans often struggle to make their own choices, meaning they don’t develop the skills needed to maintain a healthy diet in the long run. Instead, guiding clients in making better food decisions helps build lifelong healthy habits.
Ultimately, meal plans just aren’t that effective. They are something that seems like it would help, but it actually ends up being counterproductive. I have, unfortunately, coached many people who were previously given meal plans, that really struggled with their nutrition as a result. It takes a lot of extra work to help these people, as you are not just starting from scratch in terms of educating them on good nutrition practices, but you are also dealing with the fall out from the poor thought patterns that meal plans develop.
Why Writing Meal Plans is Not Within Your Scope of Practice
Many new coaches also don’t realise that creating and prescribing meal plans is often illegal unless you are a registered dietitian (RD). The laws vary by country and region, but in many places, giving a client a prescribed meal plan could be considered practising dietetics without a license.
Not only can this put you at legal risk, but it can also put your clients’ health at risk if the recommendations are not properly tailored to their specific medical and dietary needs.
So, what can you do legally and ethically as a coach?
- Educate and Guide: Instead of prescribing exact meals, educate clients on general nutrition principles. Teach them how to structure their meals, read food labels, and make healthier choices. By providing foundational knowledge, you empower them to make informed decisions rather than relying on a meal plan.
- Provide Sample Meal Ideas (Not Plans): You can share examples of balanced meals or give them a list of healthy food options. This allows them to make their own choices while still getting guidance. However, avoid creating specific meal plans unless you are legally qualified to do so.
- Encourage Self-Discovery: Guide clients to explore what works for their own body by encouraging them to track their food intake, monitor how different foods make them feel, and help them to adjust accordingly. This helps them build long-term habits instead of following temporary meal plans.
- Refer to a Registered Dietitian When Needed: If a client needs a specific meal plan due to medical conditions, allergies, or a highly specialised diet, refer them to an RD. This protects both you and your client while ensuring they get the best possible care from a qualified professional. Establishing relationships with local dietitians can be beneficial for both your clients and your business.
- Promote Habit-Based Nutrition: Instead of focusing on rigid meal plans, help clients develop sustainable nutrition habits such as mindful eating, portion awareness, and consistency in healthy choices. Teaching them to incorporate balanced meals into their lifestyle is far more effective than following a temporary plan.
By staying within your scope of practice, you not only ensure your clients receive the best support but also protect your credibility and longevity as a coach. The goal is to empower clients with knowledge and tools, not to dictate their every meal.
How to Approach Nutrition Coaching the Right Way
So, if meal plans are off the table, what’s the best way to help clients with nutrition?
1. Teach the Basics of Nutrition
Clients need to understand how food impacts their body, energy levels, and performance. Teach them about calories, macronutrients (protein, fats, and carbs), micronutrients, hydration, and how to balance meals for their goals. Provide educational materials, infographics, and simple breakdowns of different food groups so they can grasp key concepts easily. Encourage them to experiment with food choices and observe how different foods affect their mood, energy, and digestion.
Additionally, help clients understand the importance of food quality. Teach them how to identify minimally processed, nutrient-dense foods and explain the role of fibre, healthy fats, and lean proteins in promoting satiety and overall well-being. Offer simple food shopping strategies and tips on meal preparation that make it easier to maintain a healthy diet without feeling overwhelmed.
2. Use the “Plate Method”, Portion Guidance or Calorie and Macronutrient Tracking
Instead of giving specific meal plans, use simple frameworks like the plate method (half plate veggies, 20% plate protein, 20% plate carbs, and 10% plate fats) or hand-sized portion guides to help clients make balanced choices. This provides flexibility while ensuring they meet their nutritional needs.

Alternatively, if your client has very specific goals and really wants to learn more about nutrition, calorie and macronutrient tracking can be incredibly helpful.
Teach clients how to modify portion sizes based on their activity level and individual energy needs. Explain how different body types and goals, such as muscle gain, fat loss, or weight maintenance, all have different calorie and macronutrient requirements. Encourage intentional eating techniques where clients can adjust their portions based on hunger and fullness cues rather than following rigid calorie guidelines.
Provide visual guides, meal examples, and easy-to-follow meal templates that clients can personalise. Encourage them to experiment with different combinations of protein, fibre-rich carbohydrates, and healthy fats while keeping their meals enjoyable and sustainable.
3. Help Clients Build Awareness
Encourage clients to track their food, journal their eating habits, or use mindful eating techniques. This helps them recognise patterns, emotional eating triggers, and areas for improvement without rigid rules. Instead of only using strict food logging, suggest other they also keep track of their emotions and experience around food. For example, have them reflect on how they feel before and after eating.
Mindful eating can also be an effective tool. Teach clients to slow down, chew thoroughly, and pay attention to the flavours, textures, and satisfaction levels of their meals. Encourage them to check in with their hunger and fullness signals rather than eating out of habit, stress, or boredom.
Discuss emotional eating and how stress, anxiety, and other emotions can influence food choices. Help clients identify their triggers and create strategies to manage emotional eating through stress-relief techniques, movement, and self-awareness practices rather than relying on food as a coping mechanism.
4. Encourage a Flexible Approach
Teach clients that nutrition isn’t about perfection, it’s about consistency. Help them develop a mindset where they can enjoy their favourite foods in moderation while still making progress toward their goals. Show them how to adopt an 80/20 approach, where 80% of their diet consists of whole, nutrient-dense foods, and 20% allows for treats and indulgences without guilt.
Discuss how to navigate social situations, dining out, and travel without feeling restricted. Teach them practical strategies such as scanning restaurant menus in advance, focusing on portion control, and balancing meals throughout the day to accommodate special occasions.
Encourage adaptability by explaining that different life events, such as periods of increased stress, travel, or changes in work schedules, may require adjustments to their eating habits. The goal is to develop resilience and flexibility in their nutritional approach, ensuring they can maintain progress even when life isn’t perfect.
5. Support Behavior Change
Meal plans don’t change behaviour, but habit-based coaching does. Work with clients to set small, sustainable nutrition goals, such as drinking more water, eating more protein, or reducing processed foods. These incremental changes lead to long-term success.
Instead of overwhelming clients with drastic changes (as meal plans often do), help them focus on one or two habits at a time. For example, if a client struggles with eating enough vegetables, encourage them to add one serving to their lunch and dinner rather than attempting to overhaul their entire diet at once. Small wins build confidence and momentum.
Behavior change also requires accountability and support. Check in regularly to assess progress, troubleshoot challenges, and adjust strategies as needed. Encourage self-reflection and celebrate non-scale victories, such as improved energy levels, better digestion, or increased strength in workouts.
Finally, emphasise the importance of patience and long-term commitment. Sustainable nutrition is about gradual improvements, not quick fixes. Encourage clients to trust the process and focus on how they feel rather than solely on aesthetic or scale-based goals.
By focusing on education, flexibility, and long-term habits, you empower your clients to take control of their nutrition and make informed decisions that support their overall health and fitness journey.
Why Your Clients Think They Need A Meal Plan
Understanding why your clients think they want a meal plan will help you to better understand your client’s needs and to then help them to see why they don’t actually want a meal plan.
Many clients believe that having a meal plan is the ultimate solution to their nutrition struggles. They assume that if they just had a precise list of what to eat, they would finally achieve their health and fitness goals.
But in reality, what they want isn’t a meal plan at all, and what they really want is structure, confidence in their abilities, and clarity in their eating habits. As a coach, it’s your job to help them to develop these things
Why Clients Think They Need a Meal Plan
- They Want Simplicity: Clients often feel overwhelmed by the sheer volume of nutrition advice available. From fad diets to conflicting research, they’re exhausted trying to figure out what’s right for them. A meal plan feels like a simple, step-by-step solution that removes the burden of decision-making.
- They Lack Confidence in Their Food Choices: Many people struggle with knowing what to eat, how much to eat, and how to structure meals in a way that supports their goals. A meal plan seems like a shortcut to “getting it right” without having to learn the fundamentals of nutrition.
- They Think They Need a “Perfect” Diet to Succeed: Diet culture has conditioned many people to believe that strict adherence to a specific plan is the only way to see results. They assume that deviation from a structured plan equals failure, leading them to seek rigid guidelines.
- They’re Looking for a Quick Fix: Some clients believe that a meal plan will provide immediate results without requiring them to develop sustainable habits. They view it as a prescription rather than a tool for learning.
- They Fear Food Choices and Lack Accountability: When clients have struggled with dieting in the past, they may feel anxious about making the “wrong” choices. A meal plan can seem like a safety net, providing reassurance and external accountability.
How to Help Clients See That They Don’t Actually Want a Meal Plan
Instead of dismissing their request outright, use it as an opportunity to educate them and guide them toward a better, more sustainable approach.
- Acknowledge Their Frustrations and Concerns: Start by validating their feelings. Let them know you understand why they feel like a meal plan would help. Empathy builds trust and opens the door for a productive conversation.
- Ask Clarifying Questions: Dig deeper to understand their motivations. Their answers will reveal whether they need structure, education, flexibility, or confidence. Ask questions like:
- “What do you hope a meal plan will do for you?”
- “Have you followed meal plans before? What worked and what didn’t?”
- “What’s your biggest challenge with nutrition right now?”
- Explain Why Meal Plans Don’t Work Long-Term: Help them understand that meal plans don’t teach sustainable habits. Use real-life examples to show how life’s unpredictability (travel, social events, changes in taste) makes strict meal plans impractical.
- Provide an Alternative Approach: Instead of a meal plan, introduce them to tools like:
- Calorie and Macro Tracking
- The Plate Method for portion control
- A Food Framework that allows flexibility within structured guidelines
- A Habit-Based Approach, where they gradually improve eating behaviours without rigid rules
- Help Them Build Confidence in Their Own Choices: Teach clients how to listen to hunger cues, balance macronutrients, and make adjustments based on their preferences and goals. Offer them sample meal ideas instead of strict prescriptions.
- Create a Collaborative Process: Instead of dictating what they should eat, work with them to develop a system that fits their lifestyle. Teach them how to build meals based on foods they enjoy while staying aligned with their health objectives.
By shifting the focus from following a plan to developing sustainable habits, you empower clients to take control of their nutrition. They’ll realise they never needed a meal plan, they needed education, confidence, and flexibility to make the right choices for themselves.
Final Thoughts On Why Meal Plans Don’t Help Your Clients
As a coach, your role is to empower clients with sustainable nutrition strategies, not to provide rigid meal plans that set them up for failure. While meal plans may seem helpful, they don’t teach long-term habits, promote food independence, or account for real-life variables like social events, preferences, or emotional eating. Prescribing meal plans may also fall outside your legal scope of practice.
Instead, focus on habit-based coaching, flexible nutrition strategies, and education-driven guidance to help clients make informed, adaptable food choices. Teach the plate method, portion control, and mindful eating, while encouraging self-discovery and behavior change. Rather than giving them a rigid script, help them build confidence in their own choices.
Clients often believe they need a meal plan because they seek simplicity, structure, and clarity, but what they really need is the ability to make informed, flexible food decisions for life. By shifting your coaching approach, you empower clients with the tools they need to succeed, without the pitfalls of unsustainable meal plans.
You may also be interested in our article on How To Handle A Client Who Wants A Meal Plan.
We have a lot of free content available in our content hub, if you want to learn more. We specifically have a lot of content for coaches in our Coaches Corner. If you want even more free information, you can follow us on Instagram, YouTube or listen to the podcast. You can always stay up to date with our latest content by subscribing to our newsletter.
Finally, if you want to learn how to coach nutrition, then consider our Nutrition Coach Certification course, and if you want to learn to get better at exercise program design, then consider our course on exercise program design. We do have other courses available too. If you don’t understand something, or you just need clarification, you can always reach out to us on Instagram or via email.

Paddy Farrell
Hey, I'm Paddy!
I am a coach who loves to help people master their health and fitness. I am a personal trainer, strength and conditioning coach, and I have a degree in Biochemistry and Biomolecular Science. I have been coaching people for over 10 years now.
When I grew up, you couldn't find great health and fitness information, and you still can't really. So my content aims to solve that!
I enjoy training in the gym, doing martial arts and hiking in the mountains (around Europe, mainly). I am also an avid reader of history, politics and science. When I am not in the mountains, exercising or reading, you will likely find me in a museum.